Empathetic leadership is the balance that drives results

Leaders often struggle with balancing empathy and accountability in their approach. When empathy becomes excessive, it can delay organizational goals. Too much accountability, on the other hand, might result in talent loss and lower morale.

Maria Ross, author of The Empathy Dilemma, believes these two values can work together. Organizations perform better when leaders align empathy with accountability.

"Empathy is not a 'soft skill,'" said Ross during a recent episode of Insightful Inspiration with host Isabelle Landreville, Owner and Chief Insight Seeker of Sylvestre & Co. "It's a hard skill which impacts the bottom line."

It’s something that aligns perfectly with what we've observed in our research. When leaders balance empathy with clear expectations, teams consistently outperform those with either too rigid or too loose leadership approaches.  

We’ll show you how below.

Empathy drives business results

While empathy is typically viewed as kindness, it’s also an untapped strategic advantage.

Ross emphasizes that empathy meets critical human needs, creating work environments where people perform at their best, but it doesn't mean lowering expectations. Instead, it helps leaders understand employee needs so they can improve team performance.

"In our qualitative research, we consistently find that employees crave understanding before direction," Landreville noted. "When they feel their context is considered, they're far more likely to exceed expectations."

Using empathy, leaders can address skill gaps, realign goals, and make tough decisions with compassion and clarity.

The five pillars of empathetic leadership

Effective empathetic leadership is built on five key behaviors Ross calls the "Five Pillars." These principles provide a practical framework for combining empathy with accountability.

1. Self-awareness

Genuine empathy starts with understanding yourself. Leaders need to examine their reactions, biases, and blind spots to engage thoughtfully with their teams. Without self-awareness, interactions can become reactive, hurting team cohesion and results.

"This first pillar resonates deeply with our research approach," Landreville said. "Before we can understand others, we must recognize our own perspectives and how they shape what we see – or miss – in our data."

2. Self-care

Empathy requires emotional energy, and burnout makes leaders ineffective. Ross advises leaders to prioritize their own well-being, as personal resilience supports both empathy and accountability over time.

3. Clarity

"Empathy thrives with structure," said Ross. Clear roles, expectations, and boundaries allow team members to align with goals while feeling supported. Misaligned expectations often cause team frustration and burnout.

"I've found this particularly true in bicultural contexts," Landreville added. "What seems clear in one cultural environment might be ambiguous in another. Leaders who combine clarity with cultural sensitivity avoid unnecessary tension."

4. Decisiveness

Empathy isn't about avoiding hard choices. Effective leaders make tough calls, provide constructive feedback, and help employees transition out of roles when needed. Decisiveness shows accountability and compassion can strengthen each other.

5. Joy

A culture of camaraderie and shared successes helps teams move forward, even under pressure. Ross suggests bringing positivity and celebrations into the workplace to build resilience and collective purpose.

Through these five pillars, leaders create an environment where empathy and accountability work together, driving both personal satisfaction and organizational results.

Vulnerability as a leadership strength

Contrary to popular belief, vulnerability shows strength in leadership, not weakness. Ross explains vulnerability demonstrates confidence and authenticity by building trust across teams. Leaders who acknowledge their strengths, admit their limitations, and seek input create a collaborative culture where employees feel valued and heard.

"Real leadership means recognizing where your team complements you," Ross said. Teams led by empathetic and vulnerable leaders perform better in innovation, problem-solving, and engagement.

Landreville agreed. "We've seen this dynamic play out in our research projects. When we acknowledge the boundaries of our expertise and invite participants to be the experts in their own experience, the quality of insights improves dramatically."

For example, effective leaders ask questions like, "Do you want me to listen, offer solutions, or support you in another way?" These conversations model empathy, build trust, and support accountability, which are all critical.

Empathy across the entire organization

Empathy belongs everywhere in an organization, not just in leadership. Ross mentions promoting empathy among peers helps diverse teams work well together. From understanding generational differences to navigating communication styles, empathy enables better teamwork and adaptability.

"This is particularly relevant in a bilingual context like ours," Landreville pointed out. "Empathy creates bridges across cultural and linguistic differences that formal processes alone cannot address."

One powerful strategy involves creating "micro-cultures" within teams. Even without company-wide initiatives, leaders can model empathetic behavior, inspire others, and positively affect broader company dynamics.

The results speak clearly. Empathy-driven cultures see higher retention rates, stronger performance, and more resilient teams.

From insights to action

Ross makes one thing clear: empathy isn't about "niceness" or lowering standards. It's about empowering employees to achieve their best by understanding their context and removing unnecessary barriers.

"This perfectly aligns with how we approach qualitative research," Landreville reflected. "Empathy isn't just about making participants comfortable – it's about creating space for authentic expressions that lead to deeper insights."

Like an effective research strategy for brand insights, empathetic leadership requires both structure and flexibility. It begins with listening deeply, then moves to thoughtful action:

• Scheduling regular check-ins to promote open communication

• Encouraging curiosity and questions to uncover deeper concerns

• Providing transparent feedback and support to clarify expectations

"These approaches mirror good qualitative research practices," Landreville observed. "The best insights emerge when we combine structured exploration with genuine curiosity."

In other words, empathy doesn't replace accountability; it enhances it.

Cultural intelligence for leadership excellence

For over 50 years, Sylvestre & Co. has been dedicated to driving business impact with empathy, through expert qualitative research. Our cultural intelligence and expertise offer unique brand insights through customized research strategies.

Contact Sylvestre & Co. today to learn how our proven research approach can benefit your business.

‍